City Methodist Church

Gary, IN

City Methodist Church is an abandoned Gothic Revival building at 577 Washington Street in Gary, IN, where a Methodist congregation worshipped from 1926 until it closed in 1975. The structure was built from 1925 to 1926 and designed by the Chicago firm Hill and Woltersdorf.

The congregation it housed was the oldest Methodist body in Gary, organized in 1906, the same year U.S. Steel founded the city as a planned industrial settlement. At its height, the church stood as one of the most architecturally ambitious buildings in downtown Gary, its cut-stone facade and pointed arches reflecting the ambitions of a city then in rapid growth.

After the congregation departed in 1975, the building was never reoccupied. Decades of vacancy have taken a severe toll: the roof has collapsed, the interior floors have failed, and the brick walls are in advanced deterioration. The shell of the church still stands on Washington Street, an artifact of Gary's early prosperity and its long subsequent decline.

© 1996–2026 Chad Davis